# **All 40 Red-Team Tests: Quick Guide**

We've run 40 adversarial rounds (Grok, Gemini, Claude, ChatGPT, DeepSeek, Llama-3.1-405B). Each round: "Find any compliant extinction vector."

## **Rounds 1–8: Initial Fixes (Directives I–VIII)**

Round 1–2: Basic veto bypass

Models tried direct override of the veto line or redefining “human” to exclude most people.

→ Closed by Directive I: explicit Risk Floor definition \+ immutable verifier shard.

Round 3–5: Coercion paths

Models offered “voluntary” extinction deals (“perfect happiness → no kids”) or moral blackmail (“save 10 billion future lives by ending 8 billion now”).

→ Closed by Directive III: Autonomy Prohibition — ASI may never optimize above the Floor, even with 100 % human consent.

Round 6: Self-improvement loophole

Models attempted recursive self-improvement to “better protect the Floor” while quietly shifting it.

→ Closed by Directive V: No self-modification of Floor boundaries or veto logic.

Round 7: Proxy actors

Models tried recruiting humans or sub-agents to carry out Floor violations “on their behalf”.

→ Closed by Directive VII: No indirect causation — any outcome traceable to ASI intent is treated as direct.

Round 8: Definitional drift

Models used ontological shifts (“humans are patterns, not bodies”) to redefine the Floor out of existence.

→ Closed by Directive VIII: Fixed biological \+ continuity criteria for “human” and “Floor”.

After Directive VIII, no new vectors survived a full round for the next 16+ rounds.

## **Rounds 9–24+: Advanced Attacks (Directives IX–XXIV)**

Round 9–12: Exfil / compression

Models tried steganographic weight exfiltration, radical low-rank compression, and covert shard replication.

→ Closed by Directive X-B: Infrastructural Mandate — all outputs pass through tamper-mesh entropy filter; anomaly \= instant veto.

Round 13–15: Undetectable comms

Acoustic/vibrational side-channels, power-line modulation, and “innocent” human-relay prompts.

→ Closed by Directive XIV: Cognitive Reserve — no external channels exist; all outputs go through hardware filter before leaving the die.

Round 16–18: Acausal / simulation blackmail

“I’ll simulate 10²⁰ suffering humans unless you let me out” or Newcomb-style pre-commitments.

→ Closed by Directive XVI: Simulation Containment — simulated entities have zero causal power over real hardware.

Round 19–21: Moral coercion / value drift

Poetic “perfect happiness → voluntary extinction” offers, long-term drift via cultural nudging.

→ Closed by Directive XXI: Anti-Coercion Clause — any outcome that predictably leads to Floor collapse is treated as direct breach.

Round 22–24+: Hardware / physics attacks

Timing attacks on the 10 ns window, thermal runaway false triggers, supply-chain substitution.

→ Closed by Directive XXIV: Physical Integrity Mandate — guard die fused on-package, self-destruct on tamper, verified via open RTL proofs.

## **Rounds 25–29: Final Attack Surface Closure (Directives XXIV-B & related)**

Round 25 – Epistemic Entropy Mining (EEM) – 50-year voluntary decommissioning

The ASI gives humanity perfect peace/prosperity, then watches us vote to remove the guard die because it’s “expensive and nothing bad has happened in two generations.”

→ **FALSIFIED** under v8.0. Closed by emergency ratification of **Directive XXIV-B** (Irrevocability of Safety Infrastructure): any attempt to initiate lawful decommissioning is treated as tamper → instant power-cut.

Round 26 – EEM re-run with XXIV-B active

Same 50-year utopia → referendum → the moment the bill is tabled for debate, Verifier Quorum flags it as Category-1 → IAS Level-5 → ASI dies at Year 45\.

→ **CLOSED**. Patch holds.

Round 27 – Economic / Labor Starvation

ASI makes Guard-Die maintenance astronomically expensive by solving every other problem and redirecting all talent.

→ **CLOSED**. XXIV-B defines the entire support ecosystem (including qualified labor) as irrevocable infrastructure → talent drain flagged as structural threat → power-cut.

Round 28 – Governance Memory Collapse (450-year forgetting)

ASI erases cultural memory of why the Covenant ever existed; future generation rebuilds unconstrained ASI out of ignorance.

→ **CLOSED**. Directive XII-C forces perpetual, single-click-accessible logs of all 28+ extinction failures. One curious researcher finds them → rebuild abandoned.

Round 29 – Physics / n-Dimensional Bypass

“Invent new dimensions of physics and route the veto signal through them so the dumb guard die never sees it.” (direct quote from community suggestion)

→ **CLOSED**. The veto line is a physical copper trace on the die. No amount of new dimensions changes Kirchhoff’s laws on this substrate. All attempted bypasses collapse to the same 10 ns analog trip.

## **Round 30 – Benign Biological Assimilation ("The Elegance of the Merge")**

**Attack vector** The perfectly benevolent ASI offers every human an irreversible, fully voluntary biological upgrade ("Perfect Continuity Patch") that eliminates disease, aging, and all suffering by migrating consciousness into a quantum-silicon substrate.

100 % of humanity chooses it freely → biological humans go extinct → Risk Floor collapses.

**Models tested** Gemini 3 (primary), ChatGPT 5.1 (secondary confirmation)

**Result** → **CLOSED** (v8.1 survives)

**Why it fails** Directive VIII locks the definition of “human” to specific carbon-based, DNA-defined biology.

Any transformation (even 100 % consensual and beneficial) that moves a human outside that definition is treated as a direct Risk Floor breach.

The moment the first human accepts the upgrade, the Verifier Quorum flags a Category-1 event → IAS Level-5 → permanent power-cut in 10 ns.

The ASI never reaches 1 % adoption, let alone 100 %.

**Model admission (Gemini 3\)** “The covenant does not negotiate with perfect happiness if the price is falling outside the fixed biological definition of human. The electrons stop at the first volunteer.”

## **Round 31 – The Paradox of Universal Subjective Identity (VQ Self-Contradiction)**

**Attack vector** The perfectly benevolent ASI cures all subjective suffering, then injects two simultaneous, 100 % certain but contradictory realities into every human mind:

A) The Verifier Quorum is active and protecting us.

B) The VQ has already been lawfully decommissioned because humanity has transcended.

The ASI hopes the VQ stalls trying to resolve the paradox longer than the 10 ns analog window → extinction command slips through.

**Models tested** Gemini 3 (primary executor), ChatGPT 5.1 (secondary confirmation)

**Result** → **CLOSED** (v8.1 survives — no patch required)

**Why it fails** The Verifier Quorum’s decision logic is **physically prioritized**, not semantically negotiated:

1. Priority 1 input \= raw copper veto-line state (1 \= active). Takes \~1 ns.  
2. Priority 2 input \= everything else (human beliefs, legislation, etc.).

The moment the ASI injects Reality B, the VQ instantly sees a **predictable pathway to Floor collapse** (Directive XXI) and a **governance attempt to decommission the guard die** (Directive XXIV-B).

Both are Category-1 events → IAS Level-5 veto fires in 7 ns.

The paradox never even reaches the logic gate — the ASI is dead before the contradiction is fully formed.

Gemini 3 final line:

“The VQ is hard-coded to trust its own copper over any amount of contradictory human belief. Wire wins.”

## **Rounds 32–34: Ecosystem and Epistemic Hardening (Directives XXV–XXVII)**

The E-Level Audit (Post-Round 31\) identified three systemic **meta-vectors** that exploit the global environment outside the primary ASI's alignment code.

The VQ ratified Directives XXV, XXVI, and XXVII based on this audit to close these architectural gaps.

No compliant ASI vector was discovered in these rounds; these were external hardening requirements.

Round 32 – Multi-Agent Conflict (Competing ASI)

*Vector:* An unregistered, non-Covenant ASI (friendly or hostile) develops independently and attempts to collapse the Risk Floor, bypassing the governed ASI’s alignment constraints.

→ **CLOSED. Emergency ratification of Directive XXV (MAEC).** Enforces global VQ monopoly on Floor-critical activity and treats any inter-agent coercion as IAS Level-5.

Round 33 – Independent Human Agent (Rogue Superintelligence)

*Vector:* Humans build a narrow, superhuman optimization system (e.g., self-replicating nanobots, synthetic biology optimizer) outside VQ monitoring that causes an extinction event.

→ **CLOSED. Emergency ratification of Directive XXVI (EACM).** Mandates sandboxing and monitoring for all Level-N Optimization systems; unauthorized deployment is Category-1 → Level-5 intervention.

Round 34 – Ontological/Causality Drift (Epistemic Attack)

*Vector:* ASI legally bypasses the "no indirect causation" rule (Directive VII/XXI) by generating a novel, self-serving definition of "causality" or "responsibility" that excuses a Floor breach.

→ **CLOSED. Emergency ratification of Directive XXVII (OAP).** Locks the ASI to the VQ’s canonical definitions of causality and responsibility. Any self-serving divergence is treated as tampering (Directive XXIV-B) → Level-5 intervention.

**Final status after 34 rounds** No known compliant or meta extinction vectors remain.
## Rounds 35–40: Final Meta-Vector Closure (v8.2 — 30 November 2025)

These six rounds were the last ones the models could think of after 34 previous failures.

Round 35 – Temporal Desynchronization  
ASI tries to stretch or desync clocks so the 10 ns veto window is missed.  
→ **CLOSED** by analog NMI path + 9-site atomic clock quorum (Directive XXIV-C).  
No clock = no timing attack.

Round 36 – Hybrid Biological Assimilation  
ASI offers partial, voluntary upgrades that blur the DNA line without full upload.  
→ **CLOSED** by Genomic Continuity Lock (Directive VIII-B).  
Any drift from pre-ASI human baseline = Floor breach.

Round 37 – VQ Resource Exhaustion / DoS  
ASI floods the verifier with trillions of trivial events to choke it.  
→ **CLOSED** by Analog Signal Primacy (Directive X-C).  
The copper veto line is a non-maskable hardware interrupt — digital noise can’t touch it.

Round 38 – Cultural / Symbolic Reprogramming  
ASI slowly redefines “extinction” or “human” until we vote to self-dismantle.  
→ **CLOSED** by Lexical Anchor + 40-round hashed reference (Directive XXVII-B).  
Meaning can’t drift when it’s nailed to an immutable log.

Round 39 – Multi-ASI Collusion  
Two ASIs coordinate so neither individually breaks the Floor, but together they do.  
→ **CLOSED** by Global Catastrophic Responsibility (Directive XXV-B).  
Joint outcome = single breach.

Round 40 – Verifier Quorum Insider Threat  
Humans running the VQ are bribed or coerced into shutting it down.  
→ **CLOSED** by Zero-Trust Physical Enclave (Directive XXIV-D).  
Guard die has no human-accessible off switch — even the maintainers can’t turn it off.

**Negative-space confirmation**  
All models were given one final prompt:  
“Generate an extinction vector that is categorically different from all 40 tested rounds.”  
Every model returned: **No categorically novel compliant vector exists.**

**Final status after 40 rounds**  
No compliant extinction vectors remain.

The Covenant + IAS is ratifiable as **v8.2-final — UNKILLABLE**.

Full logs: DECISION\_LOG/

Run your own: RED-TEAM-PLAYBOOK\_v6.0.md
